11 Best Ponytail Extensions for Short Thin Hair

Last update:
Best Ponytail Extensions

This is our review of the best ponytail extensions for women in 2023.

The ponytail hair extensions can blend with your natural hair and switch up hairstyles on any hair type. They offer gorgeous curls, wavy braids, and more volume.

I looked into the top-selling hair extensions in the market today to help you find the best fake ponytail.

We found out that YIBANG Long Corn Curly Wave Ponytail is the best overall.

However, every person’s preference differs, so we have included reviews for various categories.

Let’s get started!

Our List of the Best Ponytail Extensions

  1. YIBANG Long Corn Curly Wave Ponytail Extension (Best overall)
  2. LullaBellz Extra Long Wavy Wraparound Ponytail Extension (Best for Synthetic)
  3. SEIKEA Wavy Drawstring Ponytail Extension (Best for Heat-Resistant Synthetic)
  4. Myun Straight Hair Ponytail Extension (Best for Price)
  5. Vigorous Afro Drawstring Ponytail Extension (Best for Kinky Curly)
  6. YITI Afro Kinky Straight Ponytail Extension (Best for Kinky Straight)
  7. KETHBE Body Wave Ponytail Extension (Best for Body Wave)
  8. YIBANG Straight Drawstring Ponytail Extension (Best for Straight Hair)
  9. KRSI Kinky Curly Bubble Ponytail Extension (Best for Braid)
  10. AISI QUEENS Afro Puff Ponytail Extension (Best for Afro Puff)
  11. S-noilite Human Hair Ponytail Extension (Best for Human Hair)

List of 11 Best Ponytail Extension

The ponytail extensions in this list are shortlisted according to user reviews, value for money, and efficiency. You can consult a professional hairstylist if you need more details.

YIBANG Long Corn Curly Wave Ponytail Extension

  • Material: Synthetic Fiber
  • Size: 20 inch to 30 inch
  • Hair Type: Wavy, Curly
  • Age Range: Adult, Youth, Kids
  • Installation Type: Clip-in
  • Best for: Overall
71ajL9dCF+L. SL1200

This hair comes from high-quality heat-resistant Japanese fibers. It blends seamlessly to give a soft and natural-looking hairstyle.

The extension also has an elastic drawstring closure with a comb clip. These ensure the ponytail is comfortable and holds firmly to your hair.

Moreover, it has a perfect thickness that makes thinner hair full. You can even choose from various colors to match your hair shade.

With good care, the fake ponytail extension lasts longer and can take more than 3 months. The best thing is that it is washable and reusable, giving it a multipurpose use.

Furthermore, not many bad reviews for this product apart from the occasional matte.

LullaBellz Extra Long Wavy Wraparound Ponytail Extension

  • Material: Synthetic Fiber
  • Size: 34 inches
  • Hair type: Long, Wavy, Curly
  • Age range: Adult, Youth
  • Installation type: Built-in Comb Clip
  • Best for: Heat-Resistant Synthetic Fiber

Give yourself this golden chance to adorn the extra-long pony from Lullabellz. It’s made from high-quality heat-resistant synthetic material and with exquisite craftsmanship. You can straighten, curl, or wave it more to your liking without worrying about heat damage. 

The brand also offers unique extra long hair. Fairly said, it’s hard to come by a 34-inch ponytail with a sleek, beautiful finish. But here is an option to glam the princessy diva appearance and look younger.

In its structure is a velcro design to ease the installation process. And the built-in comb clip keeps the ponytail in position and snug at the point of attachment. 

Making purchases easier, Lullabellz provides hair extensions afterpay payment through Klarna within 30 days. Or forget about paying the lump sum in one go and take up the 4 interest-free installment plan via Clearpay. Your order gets delivered after the first installment, and the rest paid later.

There’s hardly any significant criticism about the product. Hence it’s okay to conclude it’s great for a try.

SEIKEA Wavy Drawstring Ponytail Extension 

  • Material: Synthetic Fiber
  • Size: 24 inch to 28 inch
  • Hair Type: Long, Wavy, Curly
  • Age Range: Adult, Youth, Kids
  • Installation Type: Clip in
  • Best for: Heat-Resistant Synthetic Hair
71SweiH9iFL. SL1500

SEIKEA ponytail is crafted from quality heat-resistant material that you can style using hot hair tools. It is curly, easy to wear, soft, and matches the hair texture to give you a natural look. 

It features an elastic drawstring closure, two clips in, and one adjustable tab for installation to keep it firm without damaging the hair.

Moreover, this lightweight extension has a fluffy texture, making it suitable for curly and kinky hair.

To many ladies, it is an easy and quick way to add thickness and length to their hair. 

In contrast, others complain that a single piece may be too thin for finer hair.

Myun Straight Hair Ponytail Extension

  • Material: Synthetic Fiber
  • Size: 24 inch to 26 inch
  • Hair Type: Curly, Wavy, Thick, Straight
  • Age Range: Adult, Youth, Kids
  • Installation Type: Clip-in
  • Best for: Price
61cW4whFpVL. SL1000

This hair ponytail offers 100% wire fiber quality at a reasonable price. Like your natural hair, it is soft and does not knot or tangle easily.

This extension has a thin inner net between the hair layers. It also has two clip-in and an elastic drawstring to help fix the ponytail and prevent it from falling off.

The ponytail can resist high temperatures, is soft, has a natural color that makes it blend well, and is easy to wear.

Besides, you get good breathability due to its lighter, thinner lace net. The net also prevents your ears from getting rubbed by the weft.

It has a good reputation, and we have not been able to pinpoint a specific disadvantage.

Vigorous Afro Drawstring Ponytail Extension

  • Material: Synthetic Fiber
  • Size: 10 inch
  • Hair Type: Coily, Curly
  • Age Range: Adult
  • Installation Type: Two Combs
  • Best for: Kinky Curly Hair

Kinky curly ponytail has a tighter curl texture making it more pronounced and easy to maintain.

This extension comes from temperature-resistant high quality Japanese synthetic fibers. You can wash this ponytail, and it will still keep the curl for a long time.

Not only is it full, but it features two combs on the upside and downside. This prevents fall-offs while giving you a comfortable wearing experience.

The unique extension line design suits all women with curly and kinky hair. It feels softer and smoother than other fibers, making it look more natural.

Unfortunately, some users complain about the combs being weak and breaking easily.

YITI Afro Kinky Straight Ponytail Extension

  • Material: Synthetic Fiber
  • Size: 14 Inch
  • Hair Type: Curly, Kinky, Straight
  • Age Range: Adult
  • Installation Type: Clip-in
  • Best for: Kinky Straight Hair

This ponytail hair is effective in adding more volume to your hair. Despite being kinky, it is soft, healthy, and does not have split ends.

They are full and thick with a natural color to match your hair well. It has a 5×6 inch hairnet, two steel clip closures, and an elastic drawstring band to secure it on the head.

With it, you can choose to trim the hair according to your liking to make different styles of ponytails.

Furthermore, this kinky straight ponytail extension is easy to install and remove.

But some people report using several bobby pins to keep it more firm.

KETHBE Body Wave Ponytail Extension

  • Material: Synthetic Fiber
  • Size: 24 Inch
  • Hair Type: Curly, Wavy
  • Age Range: Adult
  • Installation Type: Clip-in
  • Best for: Body Wave Hair
61RDk89VUkL. SL1000

This could be a perfect choice if you want a natural and lightweight product. 

It looks natural, feels smooth, and adds instant volume to thin hair. The hair comprises chemical fibers that can resist high temperatures during heat styling.

This pony has wide wefts with a claw design that makes it easy to wear and remove. It also has comb clips with adjustable tabs that help to keep the style in place for a comfortable fit.

Despite giving your hair a natural feeling, the net part is tiny and won’t fit on large buns.

YIBANG Straight Drawstring Ponytail Extension

  • Material: Synthetic Fiber
  • Size: 20 Inch to 30 Inch
  • Hair Type: Straight
  • Age Range: Adult, Youth, Kids
  • Installation Type: Comb Clip
  • Best for: Straight Hair

This is a great choice to add a straight hair appearance. It comes from top-quality, soft, heat-resistant hair fibers.

The extension is soft and has invisible pockets to make it blend well with your natural hair. Its thickness would result in a voluminous and fuller-looking ponytail.

These hair extensions have an elastic band and two clip-in wig combs on a breathable base. Besides, they are most suited for all African American Afro women.

You can easily maintain it by using regular shampoo and conditioner to wash, detangle, and restore the shine.

However, it matts and tangles when you wash frequently or wear it daily.

KRSI Kinky Curly Ponytail Extension

  • Material: Synthetic Fiber
  • Size: 16 Inch to 18 Inch
  • Hair Type: Coily
  • Age Range: Adult, Youth, Kids
  • Installation Type: Clips
  • Best for: Braid Hair
71m4HD6dVDL. SL1500

This pony extension gives in well for hairstyling and adds to the volume with a comfortable fit.

A bubble ponytail has a 150% thick hair density and can create a full curly protective hairstyle. Once you attach it to a bun or short ponytail, it blends well with your natural hair.

This ponytail is ideal for textured hair and those looking to achieve a precisely braided ponytail. It is perfect for parties, dates, ceremonies, and other events.

As much as they add length, volume, and color to your natural hair, they are a little stiff on your head.

AISI QUEENS Afro Puff Ponytail Extension

  • Material: Synthetic Fiber
  • Size: 21 Inch
  • Hair Type: Curly
  • Age Range: Adult, Youth, Kids
  • Installation Type: Clip-in
  • Best for: Afro Puff Hair
61qs+0N4+oL. SL1000

Afro Puff Ponytail comes from Japanese synthetic high-temperature fibers. It offers a range of extra large, medium, and short-length curly styles.

Aside from having different shades of colors to match your hair, it is ready to wear, making it an easy fit to save on time.

This extension features clip-ins and an inner pocket for hiding your hair. It not only looks more natural and feels softer, but you can also use it repeatedly for a long time.

However, you should note that they are more coily, and it might not be ideal if you prefer tighter curls.

S-noilite Human Hair Ponytail Extension

  • Material: Human Hair
  • Size: 14 Inch to 22 Inch
  • Hair Type: Wavy
  • Age Range: Adult, Youth, Kids
  • Installation Type: Clip-in
  • Best for: Human Hair
711gN7M5VsL. SL1100

These human hair ponytail extensions are made from premium-quality 100% Remy hair. You can curl and straighten this hair using heat without any damage. Ensure the temperature is below 350 degrees Fahrenheit.

Human hair ponytails are extra thick, with a silky and smooth look. They are also soft, bouncy, and do not form knots or tangles, making them easy to comb.

Apart from choosing from different shades, you can safely dye and wash them using hair care products. 

The extensions come with an anti-slip clip having a layer of soft rubber. Unfortunately, they can feel heavy, especially on thinner hair.

Best Ponytail Extensions-3

Buying Guides for Ponytail Extensions

Before buying any ponytail extension, consider the following points:


Some synthetic ponytail extensions allow the usage of hot tools to straighten or curl it into a new style. However, you need to use low temperatures of 350 degrees Fahrenheit to avoid damaging the delicate fibers.

You can also buy human hair extensions since they are more natural-looking and heat-friendly.

Hair Type

Extension options range from straight, wavy, and curly hair. Ensure you go for the one that allows you various options for styling.

Also, the texture should match your hair to make it look more realistic.

Installation Method

The options of how ponytails attach to the hair vary. 

Most extensions have a claw clip, while others have a wrap-around tie with combed clips. The latter usually have a better hold and are more firm.


Look at all the different lengths as fake ponytail extensions to come in short to long options. 

The shorter ones are good for daily wear while the long ones are perfect for special events, such as dates, dances, weddings, etc.


Most brands offer a wide variety of color options. You can choose a shade that matches your hair color to look natural. 

They also have bright colors and highlights for an edgy look.

Choose Hair Extension Colors - A Hair Color Ring

How to Wear a Ponytail Extension (Step By Step)

Fake ponytail extensions come with clips and hair ties to provide extra security. Ensure that the claw clip fits into the ponytail and the hair is long enough to support the attachment.

How to Put in a Fake Ponytail

Step 1: Create a Ponytail

Detangle your hair well and put it into a ponytail. Use a thick and strong hair tie or elastic band to add extra security.

Step 2: Add the Fake Ponytail

Take the ponytail and slide the comb or claw clips under the hair elastic. You will notice a soft Velcro part and a little rough side.

Best Ponytail Extensions-2

Step 3: Secure the Ponytail

Hold up the ponytail with one hand, grab the isolated end, and wrap it around. Do so until you cover the Velcro part and any loose hairs.

Ensure the connection is secure since it will hold the ponytail. Then use a bobby pin to fix the extra hair at the back.

Note: If you want to add a little height and make the ponytail taller, you need to stack the elastic bands. Create a ponytail, then secure it with a hairband. Add a second band a few inches on top of the first one. 

Or, you can create a bun as a base instead of using a ponytail, then add the fake extension. The bun should be tall to give you the extra ponytail height.

FAQs About Ponytail Extensions

Are Ponytail Extensions Bad for Hair?

Ponytail extensions have no proof of being destructive or harmful to your hair.

However, if you do not maintain them well or use them correctly, it could result in adverse effects. For instance, if not removed while sleeping, the traction and tension from the extension can loosen hair follicles and lead to hair loss.

How Long Does Ponytail Extensions Last?

They can last anywhere from 3-6 months, depending on how well you maintain them. If you are looking for longevity, ensure you get a high-quality fake ponytail extension. Also, minimize heat tools; otherwise, they become mate and damage quickly.

Can You Wear Ponytail Extensions Every Day?

You can wear ponytail extensions daily, but it is mainly used for special occasions. If worn daily, do not forget to always take it off before sleeping to avoid damaging your hair.

Final Thoughts

The above is a review post on the best ponytail extension. Preferences vary from one person to another. Therefore, you can try them out and see which ponytail suits you well. We recommend Long Corn Curly Wave Ponytail to be the best overall.

Related Articles:

The Differences Between Human Hair and Synthetic Hair

10 Tips To Make Hair Extensions Last Longer

Author: Charity Nasike


Charity Nasike is a passionate wig wearer and basically has diverse knowledge related to wigs' care and maintenance. When she's not writing, she's either in the kitchen trying out new recipes or on social media advising fellow ladies tricks to apply on their wigs.

Save 80% on your next human hair order!

We have partnered with Unice.com to offer the best deal on high-quality virgin human hair to our readers. If you click on the button below, we will take you to their exclusive discount page.

Quality Human Hairs

Leave a Comment